American Friends of Bar-Ilan University
  • HOME
  • ABOUT US
    •  
      • AMERICAN FRIENDS OF BAR-ILAN UNIVERSITY
      • BAR-ILAN UNIVERSITY NEWS
      • 2025 PRESIDENT’S REPORT
      • Browse past reports
      • 2024 PRESIDENT’S REPORT
      • 2023 PRESIDENT’S REPORT
      • 2022 PRESIDENT’S REPORT
      • 2021 PRESIDENT’S REPORT
  • SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY
    •  
      • LIFE SCIENCES
      • COMPUTER SCIENCE & CYBERSECURITY
      • NANOTECHNOLOGY
      • ROBOTICS & ENGINEERING
      • SUSTAINABLE ENERGY
  • JEWISH STUDIES
      •  
      • JEWISH STUDIES – Communicating the relevance of Jewish Studies and Jewish values.
      • THE LOOKSTEIN CENTER FOR JEWISH EDUCATION
      • MIDRASHA INSTITUTE FOR WOMEN
      • LUDWIG AND ERICA JESSELSON INSTITUTE
        FOR ADVANCED TORAH STUDY
    •  
      • JEWISH STUDIES – Communicating the relevance of Jewish Studies and Jewish values.
      • THE LOOKSTEIN CENTER FOR JEWISH EDUCATION
      • MIDRASHA INSTITUTE FOR WOMEN
      • LUDWIG AND ERIKA JESSELSON INSTITUTE
        FOR ADVANCED TORAH STUDY
      • BIBLICAL ARCHAEOLOGY
      • Tel Zafit Archaeological Site
  • MEDICINE
    •  
      • AZRIELI FACULTY OF MEDICINE
        IN THE GALILEE
        – Bar-Ilan’s School of Medicine in the Galilee is an institution offering enhanced education and care. 
  • CENTERS FOR ISRAEL
    •  
      • CLINICS – Giving back to the community.
      • OPTOMETRY CLINIC
      • LEGAL CLINIC
      • PSYCHOLOGY CLINIC
      • MUSIC DEPARTMENT
      • BESA
        BEGIN SADAT INITIATIVE
      • THE RUTH AND EMANUEL RACKMAN CENTER
        FOR THE ADVANCEMENT OF WOMEN’S STATUS
  • DONATE
  • Contact
Bar-Ilan University Online Newsletter
Newsletter No. 2, April 2016

Defining the State of Israel:
Jewish and/or Democratic?

“Some argue that the values of the Jewish state and the values of the democratic state cannot co-exist. I don’t believe this, and this has not been the position of the Supreme Court over the years,” said Supreme Court President Miriam Naor, in addressing a conference on Jewish and Democratic Law hosted by Bar-Ilan University’s Faculty of Law, which was supported by the Zahava and Moshael J. Straus Family Foundation.

Supreme Court President Miriam Naor
Supreme Court President Miriam Naor

Sparking lively debate among a roster of Israel’s prestigious judges, legal policy shapers and some of the finest scholars from Israel and abroad, the conference probed whether the concepts of “Jewish” and “Democratic” are complementary or contradictory terms. Sessions were moderated by leading BIU legal experts, including Prof. Yedidia Stern, Vice President for Research at the Israel Democracy Institute; Prof. Ruth Halperin-Kaddari, founding director of BIU’s Ruth and Emanuel Rackman Center for the Advancement of the Status of Women; and conference organizer, Dr. Ori Aronson, who specializes in civil procedure and constitutional law.

Finding a Common Language

Former Supreme Court President, Prof. Aharon Barak noted, “As a judge I take the phrase Jewish and democratic as a given.” In his view, Israel’s values as a Jewish state are the same universal values shared by a democratic society, and which grew out of Jewish history and tradition.

Justice Dorit Beinisch, who also presided over Israel’s highest court, observed that “The debate did not begin with the establishment of the State. The Zionist Movement had already discussed it. What was decided was that the nation state would not be a halakhic state.” Beinisch opined: “We are a divided society that must find a common language. The argument cannot be decided only in the legal realm.”

Two Fundamental Concepts

Former Education Minister and Knesset member, Prof. Amnon Rubinstein said that the word “Jewish” gives the concept “Jewish and democratic” a social, national and cultural, rather than a halakhic meaning. “I read that the concept of Jewish and democratic was born from a compromise between Rabbi Yitzhak Levy, a representative of the National Religious Party, and me. That’s true technically. For me it was not a compromise. I think that the two fundamental concepts are already included in the Declaration of Independence.”

While Prof. Amal Jamal of Tel Aviv University (TAU) contended that there is an inherent contradiction in the expression “Jewish and democratic state,” Prof. Menachem Mautner, also of TAU, asserted that the definition of Israel as Jewish and democratic, along with the status of the Arab minority, should be incorporated into the definition of the State.

Replacing the “And” with a Hyphen

Stressing that Judaism and democracy are interlinked in the identity of the state, BIU President Rabbi Prof. Daniel Hershkowitz suggested replacing the “and” with a hyphen, thus referring to Israel as a Jewish-democratic state.

The conference marked the opening of the Faculty’s new Center for Jewish and Democratic Law, which the Law Dean, Prof. Shahar Lifshitz, says, aims to provide a platform for dialogue in Israeli society and to develop new legal Jewish and democratic discourse.

Also in this issue:

President's Message - From Purim to Pesach »

We are the Champions!

Debating key global issues, BIU Model UN team members win best delegates at the 2016 international competition in Madrid where they role-played Mexico in the Historical UN Security Council and Germany in the ECOSOC (Economic and Social Council).

Groundbreaking Research Implicates RNA in Causing Cancer

A novel study conducted by BIU scientists points to an exciting new direction in cancer research.

 read more »

 

Landmark Biblical Finds and a Spicy Discovery

Unearthing one of the top ten archaeological discoveries of 2015, BIU Land of Israel Studies & Archaeology faculty have also made some spicy discoveries about the Philistine impact on Israeli flora in antiquity.

 read more »

 

Jordanian-Israeli Relations:
Above Board & Beneath the Surface

During a recent visit to Amman, Dr. Elad Ben-Dror, of the Department of Middle Eastern Studies, steps into a souvenir shop and finds a vast gap between public and underlying attitudes toward Israel. Here's his personal account.

 read more »

 

Scholars & Sources:
Biblical Creation and Modern Science

Where did the universe come from? Physics Prof. Nathan Aviezer explores how creation ex nihilo is now accepted as scientific fact.

 read more »

 
Palm trees in a lush garden with a modern tower in the background, showcasing a blend of nature and architecture.

1. WELCOME

An essential partner in Bar-Ilan University’s development, American Friends of Bar-Ilan University provides vital philanthropic support for one of the fastest growing institutions of higher education in Israel.

3. LOOK FOR

4. READ ABOUT

BIU News Topics
  • All News
  • AFBIU News
  • Archeology
  • Biomedical Research
  • BIU Happenings
  • Engineering
  • Geopolitics
  • Health
  • History
  • Innovation
  • Jewish Studies
  • Literature
  • Medical School
  • Nanotechnology
  • Profiles
  • Science
  • Torah Studies

5. GET INVOLVED

Vibrant red roses in a garden with the word "DONATE" prominently displayed, encouraging charitable contributions and support for a cause.

ABOUT US

  • HOME
  • Bar-Ilan University
  • American Friends of Bar-Ilan (AFBIU)
  • AFBIU Financial Information
  • Board of Directors
  • Contact us

BAR-ILAN HIGHLIGHTS

  • Science & Technology
  • Jewish Studies and Archaeology
  • Outreach: Centers for Israel
  • School of Medicine in the Galilee

GET INVOLVED

  • Scholarship Fund
  • Computer Science Building
  • Medical School
  • Faculty Recruitment
  • Planned Giving
  • IRA Giving
  • Israel Bonds

SEARCH

©2018 American Friends of Bar-Ilan University, all rights reserved | Privacy Policy